PLEASE HELP ME

Ok so I love this game! But I really need help with puzzle 4 (the sharp tools) Im doing exactly the right thing (lol in referring to a walk through I found on the interweb) but it doesnt work, it doesnt say "she/he sees something" will I have to start over?? Please help!

emilyosmentawesome about Virtual Villagers 2, v1.1.0